I love love love this song! And Elliott has always been my favorite bet for Season 5, so to have this sung by him, wow! He has such an amazing voice, and he was really great with the song. I love his vocal acrobatics, and I love listening to him. He’s like a breath of fresh air, he is.

Carrie has always been my favorite since she appeared in American Idol, and she has always been my bet to win the competition. Tiffany’s “Could’ve Been” is perfect for her voice, it compliments her country roots and just brings out her natural talent. I’ve always loved the country feel of her voice. So soothing.

I love Kat’s rendition of this song. Although I’m not really a fan of hers, I must admit this song suits her well. This is probably the only performance she did that I liked. I love the arrangement of the song, and she did a good job singing it.

This is Fantasia Barrino’s winning piece in American Idol Season 3… I love this performance, after hearing this, I had no doubt she would win that season… she’s just so regal, and awesome and she really nailed the song. She deserves to win!

I love the way Fantasia sang this Barbra Streisand song. It’s so sad and heartfelt, it can really move you. Fantasia really tells a story with this song… it’s great.

This is an amazing performance from LaToya London. It’s unbelievable. What I really liked about it, apart from the fact that she reached the high notes of course, was her silent confidence. Like what the judges said, she commanded the stage. Definitely an Idol Moment.

This is one of the most talked about performances in American Idol ever! Randy Jackson even thought this was the best Idol performance ever in any season. It’s a really classy performance by Fantasia… magical.

This is Fantasia’s first performance in the Top 32 category. She sang Bonnie Raitt’s “Something To Talk About” And I have to say, she made me a solid fan of hers that night. Loved the way she sang this!